American Idol Top 13: Whitney Houston and Stevie Wonder Theme — Song Picks and Suggestions

The American Idol finals are underway, and this week’s theme pairs the Top 13 with classic material: the women will tackle Whitney Houston, while the men take on Stevie Wonder. While the concept may not be the most daring of themes, it’s an opportunity for each contestant to show range, interpretation, and personality through some of the most iconic songs in pop and soul history. Below are thoughtful song suggestions for each finalist, focusing on how the choice could highlight their voice, stage presence, and musical identity.

Boys – Stevie

Phillip Phillips – “Higher Ground” – Phillip’s husky tone could lend grit and soul to this energetic Stevie number. An arrangement that balances acoustic drive with a tighter band groove would suit him, letting his vocal texture shine without over-polishing the raw edge that audiences enjoy.

Heejun Han – “You Are the Sunshine of My Life” – This tender, optimistic tune could give Heejun a chance to demonstrate warmth and charm. A light, melodic arrangement with gentle piano and subtle backing vocals would let his phrasing and expressiveness stand out.

Colton Dixon – “I Was Made to Love Her” – Colton could use this upbeat, soulful song to display a more rhythmic, soulful side. A spirited band performance with a strong groove would allow him to inject energy and show vocal agility without sacrificing his natural tone.

Deandre Brackensick – “Overjoyed” or “Ribbon in the Sky” – Both songs offer a platform for Deandre’s falsetto and emotional delivery. Choosing a softer arrangement would put his vocal control and sensitivity front and center, making for a memorable, intimate performance.

Jermaine Jones – “Lately” – A reflective ballad like this could be very moving in Jermaine’s hands if he nails the subtle dynamics. Sparse instrumentation—piano and a few strings—would emphasize the lyric and his ability to convey vulnerability.

Joshua Ledet – “Living for the City” – Joshua could bring real theatricality and gospel-infused power to this socially charged classic. A build from quiet storytelling into full-band intensity would give him a chance to showcase range, control, and charisma.

Jeremy Rosado – “For Once in My Life” – This upbeat standard can let Jeremy tap into emotional sincerity while keeping a playful, soulful delivery. A bright, horn-accented arrangement would help highlight his joyful interpretation and connection with the audience.

Girls – Whitney

Jessica Sanchez – “One Moment in Time” – Jessica’s voice is well-suited to big, cinematic ballads. Choosing this song would allow her to demonstrate power and sustained phrasing, ideally with tasteful dynamics that build to a memorable climax without overwhelming the sentiment.

Skylar Laine – “I Will Always Love You” – While an obvious pick, Skylar could bring a country-tinged interpretation that honors Whitney’s legacy while staying true to her roots. A stripped-back arrangement that leans on vocal nuance and emotional honesty would be effective.

Elise Testone – “Saving All My Love for You” – Elise’s bluesy, sultry style could pair well with this romantic Whitney ballad. A smoky, jazz-tinged arrangement would help her emphasize tone color and phrasing, making for a sophisticated, grown-up performance.

Hollie Cavanaugh – “Didn’t We Almost Have It All” – Hollie can rise to the challenge of a lyrical, sweeping ballad. An intimate opening that swells into a powerful chorus would give her room to show both technical skill and emotional connection.

Erika Van Pelt – “I’m Your Baby Tonight” – Erika’s warm alto would suit this song’s sensual energy. A rhythm-forward arrangement with tight backing vocals would let her deliver a confident, sultry performance without leaning only on belting.

Shannon Magrane – “How Will I Know?” – This youthful, upbeat Whitney track is a natural fit for Shannon. An energetic, playful rendition would highlight her charm and help her connect with younger viewers while showcasing vocal accuracy and stage presence.

Overall, this theme offers each contestant a chance to reimagine beloved classics in ways that showcase their individuality. The key to success will be smart arrangements, emotional authenticity, and choosing songs that complement each singer’s strengths rather than forcing them into familiar clichés. If you have other song ideas or alternate arrangements you’d like to suggest for any of the Top 13, share them—picking the right song can make all the difference on the Idol stage.