American Idol 2023 Polls: Vote for Your Favorite Top 8 Performance and Top 5 Singer — Who Was Robbed?
Last night’s American Idol episode delivered a standout Top 8 night, featuring guest judges Alanis Morissette and Ed Sheeran filling in while regular judges Katy Perry and Lionel Richie were in the United Kingdom for the Coronation Concert at Windsor Castle. Katy and Lionel also checked in via video, and several viewers noted the novelty of having royalty — including King Charles and Queen Camilla — associated with the special event. The episode combined high-profile guest mentors with strong contestant performances, making it one of the more memorable Idol nights this season.
Alanis Morissette served as an active mentor, working with the singers on interpretations of some of her best-known songs. Her coaching helped contestants refine emotional delivery and phrasing, though the short mentor segments left viewers wanting a little more behind-the-scenes insight. Ed Sheeran joined as a guest judge and lent his perspective, and the contestants were paired into duets of Sheeran’s material. Duets can be unpredictable, but these pairings largely paid off and showcased new sides of several competitors.
Across the board, the Top 8 offered some of the season’s strongest performances. A few contestants used the chance to broaden their stylistic range, while others doubled down on genre strengths with confident, polished vocals. For viewers who follow the country-leaning singers closely, the elimination of Warren Peay before the Top 5 was surprising. Warren has delivered consistently solid showcases in recent weeks, but this time his performance felt less distinctive compared with some peers who have been evolving week to week—singers like Zachariah Smith and Colin Stough, for example, who continue to expand their stagecraft and song choices.
Looking ahead, the Top 5 will perform at Disneyland Park with mentorship from Disney alum and Hollywood Records artist Sofia Carson. Halle Bailey is scheduled to appear as a guest performer. According to the show’s press materials, the upcoming theme centers on Disney classics, which should spotlight vocal versatility as the contestants tackle iconic songs. Since the broadcast falls on Mother’s Day, it’s possible the producers will incorporate a secondary theme or tribute tied to the holiday.
Mentor-driven nights like this often reveal which contestants can adapt quickly and take artistic direction well. Alanis’s input appeared to help several singers dig deeper into phrasing and emotional truth, while Ed Sheeran’s duet pairings created moments of genuine harmony and chemistry. The blend of mentorship and high-profile guest judges elevated the episode beyond a standard performance show into a coaching and collaboration showcase.
We’ll publish a roundup of poll results and audience reactions later in the week, summarizing fan favorites, surprising eliminations, and which performances generated the most buzz online.
American Idol 2023 Top 8 / Top 5 Polls and Fan Voting
Vote for Your Favorite Top 8 Performance
Cast your vote for the Top 8 performance that impressed you most. Consider vocal technique, emotional impact, stage presence, and originality when choosing your favorite.
Vote for Your Favorite Top 8 Duet
Which duet pairing delivered the best collaboration and chemistry? Vote for the duet that showcased the most balanced harmonies and memorable moments.
Vote for Your Favorite Top 5 Contestant
As the field narrows to the Top 5, who do you think has the momentum and star quality to go all the way? Vote for the contestant you support heading into next week’s Disney-themed show.
Who Was Robbed?
Did any contestant deserve to stay who was eliminated instead? Share which singer you think was unfairly sent home and why their elimination felt like an upset.
Alanis Morissette: Yay or Nay?
What did you think of Alanis Morissette’s mentorship and judging tonight? Vote whether you thought her contributions improved the contestants’ performances.
Ed Sheeran: Yay or Nay?
Rate Ed Sheeran’s role as a guest judge and the success of the duet assignments. Did his presence add to the episode’s quality?
Your feedback helps paint a clearer picture of audience opinion and highlights which moments resonated most. Stay tuned for our follow-up that compiles the poll results, fan reactions, and a closer look at the performances that defined the Top 8 night.