American Idol 2025 Top 24 Part 2 Polls: Vote for Your Favorite Performance and Predict Who Will Leave
Voting is now open for the second half of the American Idol 2025 Top 24. The second group of 12 performers took the stage Monday night, and viewers across the country are deciding which singers will advance and which will be sent home. Two contestants will be eliminated from each night of competition, and the judges’ critiques plus audience voting will determine who makes the Top 20 for next Sunday’s Easter worship-themed special.
Below is a rundown of notable performances, predictions, and our voting prompts based on the April 14th broadcast. Please cast your votes in the polls and share which performances stood out to you. This article highlights top contenders, underrated talents, and a few performers who may be at risk.
A few notes on The Top 24 Part 2
Season 23 of American Idol has steadily improved as contestants began performing full arrangements with the live band. Night 2 offered several memorable moments and revealed a clearer picture of who might contend for the title. Thunderstorm Artis delivered a commanding performance and should be considered a Top 10 frontrunner. His stage presence and vocal control made him one of the evening’s most impressive acts.
Kyana Fanene remains one of the show’s greatest vocal talents, despite receiving limited screen time so far. Her vocal tone and phrasing set her apart, and many viewers feel she could be underappreciated if exposure stays minimal. Desmond Roberts also impressed with a collaborative performance where he and the band fed off one another’s energy, producing a lively and dynamic rendition of his song.
Canaan James Hill and Mattie Pruitt experienced off nights, but both have built enough momentum and visibility to likely advance. Canaan’s devoted fan base and consistent charisma should carry him forward, and Mattie has demonstrated the ability to rebound in subsequent performances. Amanda Barise surprised by stepping outside of a predictable “diva” mold; her jazzy take on a classic showcased versatility and musicality that could help her stand out in future rounds.
The house band deserves recognition as well. Their recent arrangements have been more ambitious and supportive, allowing singers to explore stylistic choices and highlight their strengths. Production and musical direction have provided contestants with opportunities to elevate familiar songs into fresh interpretations.
One more note
Polls predicting eliminations will close on Wednesday, April 16 at 8:00 PM ET/PT. The Top 20 round is expected to film that day, and results or spoilers may surface before the episode airs. To keep our polls fair and avoid influence from confirmed outcomes, the voting window is intentionally limited. We will publish the results from both polls later in the week so readers can see how closely the crowd’s predictions matched the official eliminations.
If you follow spoilers or insider updates, please consider that early knowledge of outcomes can skew poll results. Fans who prefer an unspoiled experience can still participate in the performance-vote poll to show support for standout singers without trying to predict eliminations.
American Idol 2025 Top 24 Pt 2 Polls
Which TWO contestants will be eliminated? (Pick TWO)
Poll widget: Choose the two contestants you predict will be eliminated from Night 2. Voting is limited and will close at the announced time. Please select carefully and check back later for results and analysis.
Vote for your favorite performance
Poll widget: Vote for the night’s most memorable performance. Which artist delivered the standout vocal, emotional connection, or inventive arrangement that earned your support? Cast your vote now and return to see how fan favorites compare.
Final thought: Night 2 reinforced that this season contains real depth. Expect surprises as screen time, song choice, and running order continue to shape viewer perception. Keep an eye on Thunderstorm Artis, Kyana Fanene, Desmond Roberts, Amanda Barise, and other contestants who combined strong vocals with compelling stagecraft. Tune in next Sunday for the Easter Worship special when the Top 20 is revealed, and be ready to vote again as the competition intensifies.