
Dancing with the Stars 35 Recap: Week 5 — Super Bowl Night
Welcome to our recap of Week 5 of Dancing with the Stars Season 35. This week’s theme was Super Bowl Night, with the ballroom paying tribute to some of the most memorable halftime shows. The episode featured guest judge Joe Buck and several former contestants and football stars joining the pros for special halftime-inspired numbers.
Last week’s show was Mariah Carey night, and most couples showed improvement. Maura & Mark led the pack, while Guillermo & Witney landed at the bottom. Ciara & Brandon were eliminated after a strong final performance, demonstrating how crucial audience voting remains in the competition.
Live voting opens at the start of the show and closes before the final commercial break. You can vote online at dwtsvote.abc.com or by texting the celebrity’s name to 21523. Each voting method allows up to ten votes per couple for a combined total of twenty votes per viewer.
Football Stars Emmitt Smith and Donald Driver Join the Pros
The show opened with an energetic halftime-style routine featuring the pros, troupe members, and former contestants, joined by football legends Emmitt Smith and Donald Driver. The number, choreographed by Jamal Sims, included a dramatic drum section and plenty of big production energy. Hosts Alfonso Ribeiro and Julianne Hough introduced the night, and Joe Buck was welcomed at the judges’ table.
VOTING is now open.
Maura & Mark — Tango
Maura delivered an impressive Tango with strong turns, controlled posture, and moments of Argentine Tango flavor. Her technique and presence suggested steady growth and confidence on the dance floor.
Judges’ comments: Joe Buck praised her posture. Bruno called it thrilling from start to finish. Carrie Ann found it beautiful but suggested sharper punctuation on some moves. Derek noted neck positioning and asked for more attack in future dances.
Carrie Ann 8, Derek 8, Joe 9, Bruno 8 = 33/40
To vote for Maura, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text MAURA to 21523.
Jackson & Emma — Salsa
Jackson brought energy and charisma to a lively Salsa. His solo moments showed unexpected skill and enthusiasm. The routine loosened a bit toward the end, but he stayed in sync with Emma and kept the tempo and smile throughout.
Judges’ comments: Bruno acknowledged improvement but flagged underarm passes and lifts for refinement. Carrie Ann praised his confidence. Derek called it his best dance so far. Joe congratulated his contributions to baseball and his performance.
Carrie Ann 8, Derek 8, Joe 8, Bruno 7 = 31/40
To vote for Jackson, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text JACKSON to 21523.
Amber & Pasha — Samba
Amber delivered a sizzling Samba with dynamic hip action, energetic solos, and solid Samba rolls. Pasha’s choreography leaned into the Super Bowl theme while showcasing authentic Samba flavor and strong stage presence.
Judges’ comments: Carrie Ann said Amber fully owned the routine. Derek called it fierce. Joe described it as hot, and Bruno praised the variety in her interpretation.
Carrie Ann 8, Derek 9, Joe 9, Bruno 8 = 34/40
To vote for Amber, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text AMBER to 21523.
Tyler & Sharna — Jazz
Tyler continues to show steady improvement. While not a natural dancer, he committed to the Jazz routine and maintained strong energy. Some steps still require polish, but his timing and lifts were notable highlights.
Judges’ comments: Derek applauded his effort. Joe expressed pride. Bruno and Carrie Ann both recognized progress and appreciated the partnership.
Carrie Ann 8, Derek 7, Joe 8, Bruno 7 = 30/40
To vote for Tyler, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text TYLER to 21523.
Connor & Rylee — Samba
Connor’s youthful energy was on full display. He tackled challenging Samba moves with enthusiasm, though some Samba rolls and timing moments needed refinement. His commitment and stage presence made the routine entertaining.
Judges’ comments: Joe noted the crowd’s affection for him. Bruno and Carrie Ann pointed out timing and hip action to work on. Derek enjoyed the joy Connor brings but emphasized continued technical development.
Carrie Ann 6, Derek 6, Joe 7, Bruno 6 = 25/40
To vote for Connor, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text CONNOR to 21523.
Former Contestants and Football Stars Take the Floor
Former contestants and football stars—Donald Driver, Emmitt Smith, Danny Amendola, and DeMarcus Ware—performed a celebratory routine choreographed by Jamal Sims, continuing the Super Bowl halftime tribute theme.
Julia & Ezra — Jazz
This routine blended hip-hop and freestyle elements with strong solo moments from Julia. Her solo section stood out for confidence and precision, and Ezra’s chair work added memorable visual detail.
Judges’ comments: Bruno praised her hip-hop interpretation. Carrie Ann and Derek both complimented the performance, and Joe suggested she could have performed at a Super Bowl halftime show.
Carrie Ann 8, Derek 8, Joe 9, Bruno 8 = 33/40
To vote for Julia, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text JULIA to 21523.
Tatyana & Jan — Salsa
Tatyana brought grit and personality to her Salsa. The performance was strong and emotionally committed, though a touch more classic Salsa precision would elevate the technical score.
Judges’ comments: Carrie Ann noted clear improvement and smoothness. Derek wanted more closed-foot finishes. Joe called it his favorite of the night, and Bruno encouraged a bolder, Tina Turner–style energy.
Carrie Ann 7, Derek 7, Joe 8, Bruno 7 = 29/40
To vote for Tatyana, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text TATYANA to 21523.
Guillermo & Witney — Salsa
Guillermo embraced the theme with characteristic humor and enthusiasm. Technically the Salsa showed effort but lacked consistent rhythm and foot placement. Witney, visibly pregnant, continued to partner with focus and care.
Judges’ comments: Derek joked about his future as a halftime headliner. Joe praised the couple’s progress, and Bruno and Carrie Ann highlighted connection and effort.
Carrie Ann 6, Derek 5, Joe 6, Bruno 5 = 22/40
To vote for Guillermo, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text GUILLERMO to 21523.
Jenna & Val — Paso Doble
Jenna delivered a textbook Paso Doble with powerful lines, precise execution, and commanding theatricality. Val’s classical approach allowed Jenna’s strength and dramatic expression to shine.
Judges’ comments: Joe and Bruno praised the performance’s impact and technical excellence. Carrie Ann called it a touchdown of the night, and Derek labeled it a Super Bowl championship performance.
Carrie Ann 9, Derek 9, Joe 9, Bruno 9 = 36/40
To vote for Jenna, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text JENNA to 21523.
Harry & Jenna — Samba
Harry’s hip-hop background blended with Samba elements to create an eclectic, high-energy routine that suited his style. While some traditional Samba technique could be tightened, the performance was entertaining and well-executed.
Judges’ comments: Bruno and Derek pointed out heel leads to correct, while Carrie Ann and Joe praised the overall performance and lift work.
Carrie Ann 8, Derek 8, Joe 9, Bruno 8 = 33/40
To vote for Harry, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text HARRY to 21523.
Ezra & Daniella — Salsa
Ezra’s athleticism and stage charisma were on full display in a polished Salsa that blended swagger with precise partner work. Daniella highlighted his strengths while maintaining strong technique and storytelling.
Judges’ comments: Carrie Ann called it a masterclass in musical interpretation. Derek complimented Ezra’s control, Joe praised his star quality, and Bruno described the performance as smoldering.
Carrie Ann 9, Derek 9, Joe 9, Bruno 9 = 36/40
To vote for Ezra, visit dwtsvote.abc.com or text EZRA to 21523.
Judges’ Scores for Week 5 (Out of 40)
Jenna — 36
Ezra — 36
Amber — 34
Maura — 33
Julia — 33
Harry — 33
Jackson — 31
Tyler — 30
Tatyana — 29
Connor — 25
Guillermo — 22
Voting has now closed.
Results
The following couples are safe and will return next week: Julia & Ezra, Maura & Mark, Jackson & Emma, Harry & Jenna, Amber & Pasha, Ezra & Daniella, Jenna & Val, Tatyana & Jan, Connor & Rylee, and Tyler & Sharna.
Eliminated this week: Guillermo & Witney.
Guillermo thanked the audience and the show for the opportunity, and Witney expressed gratitude for their season together and reflected on how empowering the experience has been.
Although Guillermo brought consistent entertainment value, his elimination reflects the judges’ assessments of technical progress among the remaining competitors. Witney delivered a strong season as both partner and choreographer; the audience will also wish her well with her pregnancy.
Next Week — Dedication Night
Next week’s theme is Dedication Night, when contestants dedicate performances to special people in their lives. Expect emotional moments and on-floor reunions as loved ones join the dancers. Guest judge Kym Johnson will return to the panel.
Thanks for following this Super Bowl–inspired episode recap. Be sure to tune in next week for Dedication Night and continued competition on Dancing with the Stars.







