American Idol 2025 Top 10 Ranked: How Would You Rate the Contestants? Plus Facebook Numbers
American Idol 2025 continues to air live across the country. On Sunday, May 4, the Top 10 will perform songs that honor iconic women in music, with Miranda Lambert serving as mentor. At the end of that episode a Top 8 will be revealed. The following night the Top 8 will each perform a song secretly suggested by the judges — contestants will choose one of three options, and the judge with the most selections earns bragging rights. America will then vote to select a Top 6 and the judges will add one act to complete the Top 7.
With a pivotal week ahead, now is a good time to rank the Top 10 based on momentum, past performances and public engagement. Below you’ll find Facebook view counts from the recent Top 12 performance clips, followed by an ordered assessment of each contestant’s current standing and prospects.
American Idol Top 12 Performance Facebook Rankings
These figures reflect Facebook views and likes for the Top 10 performance videos posted after the Top 12 episode. They provide a useful snapshot of viewer interest and social reach heading into the next rounds.
- John Foster – “I Told You So” – 7.1M views, 116K likes
- Gabby Samone – “A Song for You” – 2.5M views, 33K likes
- Jamal Roberts – “Heal” – 1.9M views, 34K likes
- Breanna Nix – “Tell Your Heart to Beat Again” – 504.4K views, 11K likes
- Canaan James Hill – “Goodness of God” – 358.8K views, 7.7K likes
- Josh King – “All by Myself” – 339.4K views, 4.1K likes
- Mattie Pruitt – “Because of You” – 253.5K views, 3.1K likes
- Thunderstorm Artis – “House of the Rising Sun” – 200.9K views, 3.9K likes
- Kolbi Jordan – “Over the Rainbow” – 195.4K views, 4.1K likes
- Slater Nalley – “Angel from Montgomery” – 190.7K views, 4.2K likes
Based on these numbers, John Foster, Gabby Samone and Jamal Roberts lead in social reach, each exceeding one million views. John’s clip stands out with more than 7 million views, while Gabby and Jamal each have strong, multi-million view counts. The remainder of the Top 10 have yet to break half a million views on their most recent clips, so the gap in social traction is notable and could influence voting patterns.
American Idol 2025 Top 10 Rankings
Rankings can change quickly on a live competition, and early favorites can fall as viewers respond to each new performance. The order below reflects current momentum, vocal performance consistency, song choices and audience engagement on social platforms.
10. Kolbi Jordan
Kolbi holds a Platinum Ticket and delivered a memorable “Amazing Grace” on Songs of Faith night. Nevertheless, her niche in R&B and gospel competes directly with stronger-performing R&B singers in the field. With lower Facebook views compared to the frontrunners, Kolbi is at risk of elimination this week unless she connects with voters in a different way or earns a judges’ save if needed.
9. Mattie Pruitt
Mattie began the season strongly but her recent shows have been uneven. She has a mature tone and technical skill, yet some performances lacked the emotional intensity necessary for songs like Janis Joplin’s “Piece of My Heart.” Her “Because of You” felt restrained, leaving questions about whether she can consistently capture the raw energy required to advance deep into the competition.
8. Thunderstorm Artis
Thunderstorm arrived with strong expectations but his social numbers suggest his performances aren’t gaining widespread traction. His take on “House of the Rising Sun” attracted modest attention compared to the show’s top clips. He remains a talented and distinctive singer, but so far that uniqueness hasn’t translated into the same level of viewer momentum as others.
7. Slater Nalley
Slater brought noteworthy Americana sensibilities to the competition, but his approach appeals to a narrower audience. Country-centric viewers currently favor John Foster’s more mainstream country selections. Despite strong artistry, Slater’s mid-pack social engagement and song choices may limit his ability to climb higher without a breakout moment.
6. Josh King
Josh is the lone judges’ wildcard from the Top 14 still standing and has proven his versatility with upbeat numbers and heartfelt ballads. He appears musically confident and knows how to choose songs that showcase his strengths. With recent eliminations thinning the field, Josh’s consistent stage presence keeps him a solid contender for the next rounds.
5. Canaan James Hill
Canaan’s powerful voice and heartfelt performances, often rooted in faith-based music, resonate strongly with viewers. He projects sincerity and warmth, though he’s still developing his stage confidence and broader audience connection. At his age, his potential is clear, and he’s well-positioned to remain in the Top 5 if he continues to grow.
4. Breanna Nix
Breanna sometimes battles visible nerves, but when she lets go on stage she delivers impressive vocal power. Her strengths shine on big ballads and worship-leaning material, and she showed impressive range with Journey’s “Open Arms.” If she can build confidence, she could climb higher, but inconsistency keeps her just outside the top three for now.
3. Gabby Samone
Gabby’s momentum accelerated in Hollywood Week when judges fast-tracked her past the Head-to-Head round. Since then she has delivered consistently strong performances, from soul and Broadway-tinged pieces to contemporary standards. Her theatrical flair and fresh interpretations have earned significant social engagement and make her a clear Top 3 contender.
2. Jamal Roberts
Jamal is one of the season’s most versatile entertainers. His performances combine energetic showmanship with emotional depth, and he moves comfortably across genres. A recent standout was his powerful take on Tom Odell’s “Heal,” which highlighted his ability to choose unexpected material and make it undeniably his own. Jamal’s consistent impact makes him a top favorite.
1. John Foster
John has risen quickly and currently holds the top spot in this ranking. The 18-year-old’s warm, radio-ready country tone and emotionally resonant performances have struck a chord with viewers. His rendition of “I Told You So” moved the judges and generated extensive press and social buzz, reflected in more than seven million Facebook views. If he continues on this trajectory, John is a strong candidate to win the season.
American Idol airs Sunday and Monday at 8:00 PM on ABC and streams the next day on Hulu.