American Idol Top-3 Poll Results: Winners, Fan Favorites, and Predictions

The poll results are in, and for the most part they confirm what many fans were already thinking. Voters picked their favorite performances, their preferred contestants, and weighed in on which of the Top 3 should or will be leaving the competition. Below is a clear breakdown of the results and what they likely mean for the finals.

Favorite Performances

Leading the performance poll was Candice Glover’s rendition of “Somewhere,” which earned 33% of the vote and a decisive lead over the rest of the field. Kree Harrison’s performance of “Here Comes Goodbye” finished second with 26%. Angie Miller’s rendition of “Try” placed third, while her take on “Sorry Seems to Be the Hardest Word” ranked fourth with 12% of the vote. The remaining songs received less than 5% each, with Kree’s versions of “Better Dig Two” and “Perfect” rounding out the bottom of the list.

These results highlight how standout moments—songs that emotionally connect or showcase vocal control—resonate with fans. Candice’s clear lead suggests her performance struck a broad chord with voters, while Kree’s strong showing keeps her competitive in the eyes of many viewers.

Favorite Contestant and Voting Breakdown

The race for favorite contestant is extremely close. Candice Glover narrowly edged out Angie Miller by less than one percentage point; both sit at approximately 36% of the vote each. Kree Harrison trails at 27%. These numbers suggest a highly engaged fanbase split mainly between Candice and Angie, with Kree maintaining a solid but smaller bloc of support.

When asked about themes, voters favored “Judges’ Choice” by a wide margin—70% selected it as their preferred theme night. “Producers’ Choice” followed at 17%, and “Jimmy’s Choice” received 12%. That strong preference for Judges’ Choice indicates audiences enjoy seeing artists interpret songs chosen by industry pros rather than relying solely on producer picks or a single mentor’s selections.

Who Should Go Home vs. Who Will Go Home

Polls asked two distinct but related questions—who fans think should be eliminated and who they believe actually will be eliminated. Results show some divergence between perception and prediction.

• Who should go home: Kree 45%, Angie 38%, Candice 17%
• Who will go home: Kree 63%, Candice 19%, Angie 18%

Fans appear to think Kree is the contestant most deserving of elimination, and an even larger share predicts she is the one who will actually be sent home. For Angie, more people feel she should be eliminated than believe she will be. That gap can indicate belief in voting patterns or simply confidence that a contestant’s fanbase will rally to keep them in the competition.

Context and Commentary

At this stage of the competition, fans have largely chosen their favorites and are likely to stick with them. Big moment performances can still sway casual viewers, but by the Top 3, entrenched support usually wins the day. Last night’s performances offered at least one strong moment from each finalist, and while critics and judges may favor certain renditions, those moments may not be enough to shift voting habits dramatically.

The dynamic between the three finalists shows Candice and Angie commanding nearly equal support, with Kree slightly behind but still influential. Angie’s recent momentum and competitive approach have won many fans’ respect, while Candice’s consistent vocal excellence keeps her a perennial favorite. Kree showed strong rounds earlier in the season, but recent perceptions of momentum loss appear to have impacted voter sentiment.

Prediction

Based on the poll numbers and current voting patterns, the prediction mirrors what a majority of respondents expect: Kree Harrison will be eliminated tonight, leaving Candice Glover and Angie Miller to compete in the finale. If Angie reaches the Top 2 alongside Candice, it would mark notable regional representation—historically, contestants from the Northeast have reached late stages before, with past examples discussed by fans and commentators.

Ultimately, polls give a snapshot of fan opinion at a moment in time, but live voting night can always bring surprises. For now, the data points to a Candice-versus-Angie finale, with Kree likely exiting the competition. Fans will be watching closely to see whether last night’s performances change any minds or simply reinforce existing loyalties.